Finished Batman: The Dark Knight Returns by Frank Miller.
This graphic novel reinvents the legend of Batman by setting the story in Gotham City ten years after Bruce Wayne retired from being a superhero. Gotham is more violent and crime-ridden than ever, thanks to a gang calling themselves the Mutants. The gang’s reign of terror prompts Bruce to unleash his inner vigilante and become Batman once more — with some interesting results.
First of all, let me say this book is deep. Really deep. Miller has a lot to say about vigilantes versus criminals, the role of the media and police in society, and more. You could read it a couple of times and still not catch everything.
There’s a lot in The Dark Knight Returns to like, especially if you’ve ever wanted to see Batman and Superman really go toe to toe. I also liked the way Commissioner Gordon was handled — as a competant man who’s dedicated his life to his city and still has plenty of fight left in him. Plus, there are cameos by a lot of classic superhero characters.
But overall, the book just didn’t work for me. The story was okay, but I think the media hysteria angle was a little overdone. And I didn’t particularly care for the art. Pages and pages of the book consist of small, television bubbles that show news anchors reading about the latest crimes. There are also bubbles devoted to various news-debate programs that focus on whether or not releasing the Joker back into society is a good thing. (Bet you can’t guess the answer to that one.) I’m reading the book for Batman art, not television bubbles.
Plus, I thought the latest Robin was just sort of stuck in the story to save Batman on a couple of occasions. She didn’t have a real personality of her own or a lot to do, besides bail out Batman. And yes, she’s a girl, but Batman kept referring to her as boy and threatening to fire her. Weird.
I’ve enjoyed some of Miller’s work in the past, including Sin City and 300, and I guess I was just disappointed with The Dark Knight Returns, especially the art. I’m sure other folks feel different, but thumbs down from me.
Up next: The Accident Man by Tom Cain.